Migraine: Have We Been Blaming the Wrong Thing?

Stress, sleep, and food are often not the real reasons behind headache and migraine

People often say, “I know what causes my headache, it’s stress.”
Or, “It’s definitely a lack of sleep.”
Or, “Chocolate. Every time.”

This is a common belief. Most people with recurring headache or migraine have been told to “identify and avoid triggers.” It seems logical. If something appears to cause a headache, avoiding it should help, right?

But the truth is, that idea is only part of the story, and sometimes it leads people in the wrong direction.

Triggers Are Real But They’re Not the Cause

To be clear, triggers are real. Many people notice their headache is more likely after poor sleep, stress, certain foods, bright lights, or long days at the computer.

The problem is this: a trigger is not the same as a cause.

A trigger is something that happens right before a headache starts. A cause is the deeper reason your body can produce headaches in the first place.

Those two are not the same.

Why Avoiding Triggers Doesn’t Always Work

Many people work very hard to avoid their triggers.

They’ve cut out foods they enjoy.
They turn down social events.
They worry about sleep, the weather, travel, and stress.

And yet… the headache still comes.

Why?

Because most of those “triggers” are really just normal parts of life. Stress happens. Sleep changes. We can’t control the weather. Hormones shift. We use screens. The world around us is bright and noisy.

If avoiding triggers was the real answer, life would become smaller and smaller just to stay headache-free, and even then, it often doesn’t work.

A Different Way to Understand It

It is helpful to think of the nervous system like a volume control.

A part of your nervous system processes signals from your head and neck, such as light, sound, smells, movement, and physical tension. Normally, it keeps these signals balanced in the background, so you don’t notice most of them.

But for people with recurring headache or migraine, that “volume control” can get turned up too high.

Now normal signals feel bigger and more intense than they should. Light seems too bright. Noise feels irritating. Stress feels overwhelming. Even ordinary physical tension can feel like a threat.

The system isn’t damaged; it’s just set too high.

So What’s a Trigger Then?

When your system is already turned up, almost anything can become the “final straw.”

That’s what we call a trigger.

It doesn’t create the headache from nothing. It’s just the last bit of input that pushes an already sensitive system over the edge.

It’s like a smoke alarm that has become too sensitive. It doesn’t just go off for a real fire; burnt toast or steam from the shower can set it off. The toast isn’t the real problem. The alarm is just reacting too easily.

Why This Matters

If we think triggers are the main cause, the focus becomes: “What do I need to avoid?”

But if the real issue is that the nervous system is too sensitive, a better question is: “Why is my system so easily set off, and how can we help it settle down?”

That’s a very different approach. It’s not about building a smaller life. It’s about helping your system become more tolerant again.

As sensitivity goes down, many triggers quietly lose their power. The same busy day, the same bright light, even the same glass of wine may no longer tip things over, not because the world changed, but because your nervous system did.

Moving Forward

Noticing patterns can still help. But living in fear of every possible trigger usually isn’t the long-term answer.

Headache and migraine are not caused by modern life being “too much.” They happen when a sensitive system is being pushed past its current limit.

The goal isn’t to avoid life. It’s to help your system handle life again.

And that’s a much more hopeful place to start.

Until next time

If you are new to Watson Headache®, welcome to the Watson Headache® Approach, an evidence-informed practice when considering the role of the neck in Cervicogenic and Primary Headache.

Scroll to Top